Larisa Manastirli: Where is Bulgaria After Ten Years in the EU?

.

In November 2016, Bulgarian opposition Socialist, Rumen Radev, won the presidential election, defeating the centre-right speaker of parliament, Tsetska Tsacheva, an ally of Prime Minister, Boyko Borissov. The PM had pledged to step down if his candidate lost, and he did thus triggering an early election.

Larisa Manastirli, Director for Bulgaria at the European Bank for Reconstruction and Development (EBRD), which is a leading investor in the Bulgarian economy, spoke to Andrew Wrobel, about the reforms the country has introduced and the improvements that are still required, ten years after Bulgaria joined the European Union.

Larisa Manastirli (courtesy of the EBRD)

Exactly ten years ago, Bulgaria became a member of the European Union. How have these ten years changed the country?

Well, a number of infrastructure investments have been undertaken, for example we have a Metro here in Sofia, public transportation, etc., companies, the banking sector and culture have received significant support among other sectors. 

Also, the EBRD’s approach to Bulgaria has changed. Previously we were supporting the accession process and helping companies prepare for it. The first years after the accession were the peak of our investment in infrastructure. We worked with municipalities and utility companies and, most importantly, with the private sector.  It was also a period when FDI really picked up. There was a lot of interest for Bulgaria and a lot of foreign companies were entering the country, as it joined the large EU market. 

However, if we look towards the end of that ten-year period, a feeling persists that certain reforms haven’t been implemented; the pace and the quality have not been as were expected.

Has the political situation had any impact on that?

To some extent. If we look at the political situation, I think 2013 and 2014 were quite volatile. It is true that any changes in the government slow the economy down. In 2014, these internal uncertainties were compounded by the external challenges in Syria, Ukraine and Russia. 

You mentioned the fact that a lot of expectations haven’t been met.

That is correct. Many were inspired by the EU accession and we thought those issues would be sorted out quickly. Unfortunately, many rankings currently place Bulgaria among the EU countries with the highest level of corruption and with a relatively weak investment climate. There is a lot of room for improvement. 

There are complaints about public tenders, especially in the construction sector. There is a lot of discussion about how the global financial crisis has affected the level of FDI in Bulgaria and how the internal situation has had a negative impact on our returning to the pre-crisis FDI level. 

When I spoke to Bojidar Loukarsky, the Minister of Economy, in April last year during his visit to London, he said that Bulgaria remained an island of stability, both politically and economically, in Europe.

Indeed, since the autumn of 2014, when Boyko Borisov’s government came to power, and until the recent elections and the resignation of the government, Bulgaria remained a relatively stable country. 

The coalition government has had a difficult job and a somewhat slower pace of reforms is the price it has paid for political compromises. However, the situation has changed now and we are facing new uncertainties. 

We hear that Bulgarians could go to polls in the spring at the earliest. President-elect, Rumen Radev, will take over on January 22, and will dissolve the Parliament.

I am hoping to see more political stability soon. This is crucial for investors. 

So, we have another six months of uncertainty. What does it mean for the economy?

Our latest forecast, which was published in November 2016, predicted growth of 2.8 per cent in 2016 and 2017. We expect internal consumption, backed by the increased wages, to drive this growth. 

So you stick to the forecast. Do you think the current situation will have an impact on foreign direct investment?

It’s difficult to predict. Nowadays, when you look at FDI, these are mainly smaller companies which are less affected by the political situation. It is different though for larger companies, who might delay their decision to enter the market. 

In general, I don’t think we will have a drastic decrease in FDI, as we haven’t really had a boom period either. The level of foreign direct investment in Bulgaria is rather modest. 

I would like to circle back to the reforms we discussed earlier. The EBRD is known for its policy dialogue. You’ve mentioned a couple of areas that haven’t improved since Bulgaria joined the EU, in 2007, but which areas need immediate improvement?

I don’t think there is an area which hasn’t seen any improvement at all. However, these improvements haven’t met expectations as far as the pace and the quality are concerned.

Good governance and the fight against corruption are crucial areas. There was a momentum last summer, and the draft law on anti-corruption was approved in its first reading. However, with subsequent changes in the government, this momentum has been somewhat lost.

The EBRD is committed to supporting the implementation of the future anti-corruption law. We will be happy to help build the capacity of the anti-corruption bureau, the creation of which is envisaged in this law.  

We are also considering working with the commission on protection of competition. In addition, we have offered the government our support in public procurement. Positive steps were taken to enable electronic public procurement and we intend to encourage SMEs’ access to smaller public contracts. 

So, fighting corruption is critical. Any other area that seems urgent?

The judiciary system, the rule of law. The EBRD can help with training for judges on accounting, taxation, commercial and insolvency issues.

The public-private dialogue between the government and the private sector is another area. We have a lot of experience here, in supporting investment councils in the several countries where we invest. 

We are also helping develop the local capital market. There are opportunities to create alternatives to banking — the development of the non-banking financial market is crucial as small and large companies are seeking alternative sources of funding. 

Yet another area where we are trying to work with the government is the EU-funded financial instruments in Bulgaria and a new structure to create a sustainable vehicle which could be used to improve the efficiency of EU funds’ absorption.

Larisa Manastirli (courtesy of the EBRD)

So, there is quite a lot of room for improvement but going back to the corruption issue, how would you compare this to how that problem has recently been dealt with in Romania? The are comments that the perceived level of corruption is falling and it is easier to do business. The down side is that government officials sometimes delay making decisions, so as not to be thought of as corrupt.

Bulgaria is indeed often compared to Romania, including in fighting corruption.  I believe Bulgarians can draw conclusions with the Romanian experience. Bulgaria is lagging somewhat. It is behind in fighting corruption. 

But Bulgaria is not only negatives, is it?

Of course, not. Bulgaria is a wonderful country. There are the Black Sea, mountains, fabulous weather and nature. There are amazing tourist destinations, archaeological sites and cultural places. Take Plovdiv as an example.

Indeed, I spoke to the Mayor of Plovdiv last year.

The people want to live in a fair society. They want to work in order to improve the situation in their country. People in Bulgaria are very hardworking, well qualified and with a good command of foreign languages. 

Despite the brain drain, the potential is enormous. With some incentives, the demographic situation can be improved and those who left could be convinced to come back. 

There is also industry, where foreign companies can invest. Which sectors do you see as most promising? 

Bulgaria is a very good example of a diversified economy with many industries being developed. Great examples are agriculture and food production, automotive, pharmaceuticals, chemical, metallurgy, machine production, mining, tourism, services.

RELATED ARTICLES

Economy Minister: Internationalisation Is the Key To the Slovenian Economy

EY: Belarus’ IT Scene Is Thriving

High tech park minsk

Hungary Today: Potential and Challenge

Chain bridge on Danube river in Budapest city. Hungary. Urban landscape panorama with old buildings and domes of opera

Jadranka Joksimović: Serbia Takes Its Candidacy of the EU Seriously

bigstock-Joint-Press-Conference-Of-Serb-155400338.jpg

Sarajevo Stock Exchange Connected to SEE Link

sarajevo stock exchange

Croatian Salaries Are Growing in Line With Other CEE Countries

Dubrovnik Croatia emerging europe

Bosnia and Herzegovina: Focussing on Stability and Business Climate

Sarajevo Bosnia and Herzegovina - August 23 2015. View of Miljacka River in Sarajevo city

Business Standards Are High in SEE But Vary Widely

Aerial view of The Cathedral of the Assumption in Varna

Ukraine to Restart Privatisation to Realise Profits

Pricatisation electricity ukraine

Effective Policies Have Strengthened the Georgian Economy

TBILISI GEORGIA Jul. 18 2017: Bridge of Peace is a bow-shaped pedestrian bridge a steel and glass construction over the Kura River in downtown Tbilisi capital of Georgia

21st century Manufacturing Arrives at Great Stone

Great stone

Albania’s Construction Sector Supports the Country’s Growth

SARANDA, ALBANIA - MAY 18: View of the city Saranda, most important tourist attraction of the Albanian Riviera on May 18, 2017 in Saranda, Albania.

Ukraine’s Q2 Growth Climbs

kyiv ukraine emerging europe

A Risky Evaluation of Croatia’s Economy?

ZAGREB, CROATIA - JULY 17, 2017: Square Ban Josip Jelacic with tourists and trams on a summer day in Zagreb. City of Zagreb is the capital of Croatia.

Fitch And the World Bank: Economic Growth To Remain Solid Within CEE In 2016

Kosovo: A Population of Talented Young Entrepreneurs Waits at Europe’s Door

Poland’s Q2 2017 Growth Is Stronger Than Expected

WARSAW, POLAND - MAY 07, 2016: Building Palace of Culture and Science among the modern buildings of the city

SEE Link — Sharing SEE Europe’s Hopes for a Brighter Investment Future

Poland’s Business Constitution Must Be Finalised

Front of finance ministry in Warsaw Poland with a fountain framing the entrance. Could be used for images about Euro currency problems

Doing Business Across Eurasia Could Be Easier

Eurasia emerging europe schneider group

Poland Is Set To Become a Large Economic Zone

Aerial view over the building materials processing factory. View from above.

Macedonia — Stepping Out Of the Shadow Of the Balkans

Meghri Becomes Armenia’s Third FEZ

armenia emerging europe

Belarus’ Economy Is Slowly Recovering From Past Declines

Putin Urges Belarus to End Oil Transit Through Lithuania

Athens Greece - May 27 2016: Russian President Vladimir Putin delivers

EU Membership and Transition into Market Economies Have Helped CEE Achieve Social Progress

Romanian Economy Grows Fast in 2017

Brasov cityscape panoramic and aerial view over medieval architecture of Brasov town, in Transylvania Romania

World Bank’s Doing Business Report 2016 Resume For Emerging Europe

Chris Lowney — What Jesuit Spirituality Can Teach Us About Global Leadership

World Bank: Brexit Hides Greater Challenges to the European Union and the CEE Region

Air Passenger Volumes Reach Record High in the Baltics

airbaltic

Moldova Launces New e-Procurement System In Search For Positive Change

Photo team work process, holding contract hand, signs documents. Account managers young crew works with startup project.New idea presentation, analyze marketing reports.Blurred, film effect, horizontal.

Valga and Valka – Where Estonia and Latvia Work Together

Valga valka emerging europe

Non-Financial Reporting No Longer a Secondary Consideration in CEE

Serbia, Belarus and Ukraine Ranked Lowly by Wharton Business School

Kyiv Ukraine - April 172017: The postal square in Kiev on Podol the Dnipro river. view of the square from the river panorama

CEE Emigrants Could Boost Their Countries’ Economies

Londoners walking through Millennium Bridge with St.Paul's Cathedral at the background after sunset - London, UK

The Reality in Romania Exposes False Perceptions Of The Country

Lithuania Gives Innovation a StartUp

MILAN ITALY - MAY 2: People visit Lithuania pavilion at Expo universal exposition on the theme of food on MAY 2 2015 in Milan.

Digital Business Space Gives All Businesses an Office in Sarajevo

Sarajevo Bosnia and Herzegovina - August 24 2015. View from Vraca Memorial Park with building of Avaz Twist Tower

Changes Are Making Ukrainian Banking More Aligned with International Standards

After Economic Shocks Armenia Plans for Macroeconomic Stability

yerevan armenia minister of finance

Nadiya Savchenko: I Dream of a Great Ukraine

Panorama of the top part of the Andrew's Descent from Castle Hill in springtime in Kiev Ukraine.

Estcoin: Estonia’s Own Digital Currency?

1 euro coin money (EUR) currency of European Union Estonia over blue background

EconMin: Bulgaria — Number One Outsourcing Destination And an Island of Stability in Europe

Derek Chollet: There Is a Resurgence of Supporters of the Transatlantic Relationship

white house

Western Ukraine Could Be an Entry Point into the Country

More Brexit Fears As the UK Proves To Be A Needed Member

City of London view from Waterloo Bridge. This view includes: St. Paul`s Cathedral The Gherkin Tower 42 and Blackfriars Bridge.

Ukraine Is Offering Europe Unique Combat and Technological Experience

Lech Wałęsa: Hard Options Can Force Nations to Get Down to Work

Lviv Is the Pearl and the Soul of Ukraine

Latvia Urged Not to Increase Expenditure As Economy Grows

Riga, Latvia - August, 2010: Panorama view from Riga cathedral on old town of Riga, Latvia

GE Inaugurates Its New Bucharest Software Centre

Asian Outsource Developer Team Sitting At Desk Working Laptop Computer Mobile Application Software Real Office

Polish Labour Market Deficits Are Impacting All

Construction site with crane and building. Construction site in western europe - in Poland.

Mayor: Armenia And Its Capital Yerevan Offer Safe Investment And Tourism To a Growing World

Prospering Czechia Still Needs a Bigger Workforce

prague emerging europe

PE and VC Investment In CEE Is At an Eight-Year High

venture capital

Investigations Into the Corrupt Ukrainian Fuel and Energy Sectors

Ukrainian money hryvnia. The national currency. Corruption in Ukraine

Automotive and Transport Companies Dominate the CEE Region

Car bodies on the production line inside automobile factory

Do Your Homework First and Starting Business in Poland is Easier

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *