Stuck in Neutral: Georgia’s Constitutional Reforms

.

Lincoln Mitchell

About Lincoln Mitchell

Lincoln Mitchell is a writer, pundit and specialist in political development based in New York City and San Francisco. He has worked on democracy and governance related issues in the former Soviet Union, Eastern Europe, the Caribbean, the Middle East, Africa and Asia. He also works with businesses and NGOs globally, particularly in the former Soviet Union. Lincoln writes and speaks about US politics as well, and was the national political correspondent for The New York Observer from 2014-2016. Lincoln was on the faculty of Columbia University's School of International Affairs from 2006-2013 and worked for years as a political consultant in New York City advising and managing domestic political campaigns.

It has been almost five years since the Georgian Dream’s (GD) substantial and unexpected victory in the parliamentary elections in Georgia. During these five years, the frenetic pace of events that defined much of the previous nine years, when the United National Movement (UNM) was in power, has ebbed.

Georgian politics is no longer characterised by frequent widespread demonstrations, prison abuse scandals, the peripatetic and unpredictable behaviour of a president, threats of war and a manic energy, which both brought rapid reforms but just as rapidly rationalised away undemocratic excesses.

The slower pace and lack of drama that we see under the current government does not mean that nothing is happening in Georgia. The GD has had some major successes during its time in power. It has consolidated the country’s pro-western course; has reversed, or at least stopped, Georgia’s slide towards authoritarianism during the later years of UNM rule, has avoided a shooting war with Russia and has improved Georgia’s reputation as a tourist destination with an exciting food, wine and fashion culture.

As concerns democracy, the story is more complex. In most respects, Georgia is freer than it was at the tail end of the UNM period, but significant problems remain. The challenge that frames all of these problems is that Georgia is still struggling to institutionalise pluralism while simultaneously avoiding being mired once again in one-party rule. That last sentence could have been written at almost any point during this century, demonstrating the nagging difficulty of the problem.

Last year, a much anticipated parliamentary election resulted not in a more multi-partisan or contested national legislature but in a resounding victory to the GD. The primary reasons for this was not election fraud or a high approval rating for the governing party, but an opposition that was disunified and an UNM that foolishly used the election to advocate for regime change, something for which the Georgian electorate had little appetite. The result was that the GD, despite not being beloved by the electorate, won 115 of the 150 seats and was handed a constitutional majority in the parliament.

Since winning that constitutional majority the GD has proposed a series of constitutional reforms. Some, such as defining marriage as something between a man and a woman, are reactionary. Others such as abolishing the direct election of the president may seem petty, while the way amendments will change how parliament is elected will make it more difficult for opposition parties.

Collectively, these reforms are likely to strengthen one-party rule in Georgia and will create more barriers to the establishment of a strongly pluralist system. These proposals raise the spectre of  one-party rule returning to Georgia, but the process also demonstrates that, in Georgia, the constitution continues to be used as yet another tool for the ruling party to stay in power, rather than a document that established the ground rules for a democratic polity. In this respect, little has changed in Georgia. It should be remembered that the UNM frequently engaged in constitutional machinations, when they were in power, to ensure that they would remain so.

Over the last five years, the GD has demonstrated that it has not been able to solve all of Georgia’s problems, nor to consolidate democracy throughout the country or entirely shake off the influence of its founder Bidzina Ivanishvili, who has wielded extraordinary power as a private citizen, since leaving office in late 2013.

However, the GD has also shown little interest in returning Georgia to the chronic low level instability, democratic rollback and human rights abuses of the late UNM era. There is plenty to be concerned about in the constitutional reforms, but there is a fair amount of truth to the notion that if the GD wanted to either make Georgia a much less democratic country, or move it closer to Russia, it would have done so by now. Die hard UNM supporters and their most hard-line supporters, in the west, might believe this has occurred, but nobody else does anymore.

Unfortunately, it is likely that the constitutional reforms will pass. The amendments will make Georgia more illiberal, particularly in regard to LGBT rights and they will help entrench the GD as the ruling party. They will also ensure that politics remains characterised largely by the issue of democracy itself with elections that are rarely more than referenda on the ruling party. Thus, while much of the criticism of the current constitutional processes suggests that democracy is being lost in Georgia, the more accurate way to see this is that democracy has stalled in Georgia. That is not exactly good news, but it is also a reason to not give up hope and a reminder that while much has changed in Georgian politics over the last decade, much has stayed the same.

Constitutional processes and Georgian politics, in general, are made more complicated by another factor. Georgian politics have always occurred within an international context. That is still true but that context is now in a period of significant uncertainty. For the years from roughly 2008-2016, Georgia was caught between a Russian regime that had annexed a portion of Georgia, was opposed to Georgia becoming a member of NATO and in important ways never fully recognised Georgia as a genuinely independent state, and a group of western allies that saw Georgian independence as unequivocal and, with varying degrees of enthusiasm, generally wanted to see Georgia move closer to the EU and NATO. That dynamic often left Georgia in the maw of geopolitical rivalry between Russia and the West, but it was unambiguous and Georgia knew who its allies were.

That has changed a lot in the last year or so. Russia’s position remains the same, but conditions in the West, particularly the US, are different. The relationship between the Trump administration and Russia are complex and remain somewhat vague, but they are a departure from the hawkish posture of the mainstream of both the Democratic and Republican Parties.

Similarly, the democratic rollback that is occurring in the US and parts of Eastern Europe, as well as a battery of issues within the EU ranging from Brexit to refugee related crises, has cost the West a lot of leverage in places such as Europe. Earnest protestations about constitutional reform, from places such as the Venice Commission, or statements of concern from western NGOs are even easier to ignore, given these developments.

For Georgia, constitutional reforms and changing global dynamics mean that the danger, and path of least resistance, is not an authoritarian regime like the ones in Moscow or Baku. Rather, it is being stalled in a semi-democratic limbo where elections are pretty good, every decade or so power changes hands and rhetoric is always heated, but politics remains a game for the elite dominated by accusations and re-litigation of the past rather than interests competing for political outcomes.

_______________

The views expressed in this opinion editorial are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect Emerging Europe’s editorial policy.

RELATED ARTICLES

When Neutrality Isn’t an Option

President of the Russian Federation Vladimir Putin

We, the Post-Communist Generation, Have the Skills to Rid of the Past And Create Our Own Future

Poland: Is it Ready, and is it Time to Adopt the Euro?

2018 Elections — Vital Decisions for Hungary’s Future

Victor Orban energing europe

Only a United Opposition Can Defeat Poland’s Ruling Law and Justice Party

Classical building of Polish parliament. Warsaw in Poland.

Ukraine’s Reputation for Cheap Labour May Not Ring True in the Long-term

Why Was Zapad-2017 So Important?

russian tank belarus zapad

The EU’s Benign Neglect Of Eastern Europe

The Morawiecki Plan Promises a Brighter Future for Poland

CEE — Do We Need a Launch Pad For Our On-Site Tech Intelligence in the Silicon Valley

Examining How a Strong Swiss Franc Could Single-Handedly Topple Poland’s Economy

A New Division Between Eastern And Western Europe?

Let’s Stop Wasting Time Redefining our Place in Europe

Are There Differences Between How Tax Regulations in Poland and IAS Treat Intangible Assets?

Czech Republic Renaming Has Real Economic Costs

Ukraine’s Economic Recovery: Good, But Slow

ukraine money

Ex-Transition Economies’ FDI Recovery

dollar euro fdi

People Power Reminds the Government of the Rule of Law

Georgia Leads Emerging Europe in Ease of Doing Business Report

Poland’s Unicorn, Slovakia’s Flying Car and the Future of Europe

Where’s My Cheese? – The GREAT British Food Tour 2014

Cheese Shop

Georgia Still on the World Bank’s Mind

How strong is V4?

Viktor Orban

Tbilisi Calling

Tbilisi, Georgia - April 29, 2017: Tbilisi red cable car fulicular cabin and aerial city skyline panoramic view

Not All Quiet on the Eastern Front

Why Hungary’s New NGO Law Is Harmful for Business

Budapest, Hungary. Aerial view of the old city Budapest, Hungary with river and Parliament Building with cloudy blue sky

Georgia in the UK

Are Czech-EU Relations at Breaking Point?

PRAGUE, CZECH REPUBLIC - 21 JUNE 2014: People on the streets of Prague, Czech Republic. Prague is one of the most visited city in Europe with over 5 million visitors every year.

‘Traditional Values’: A Potent Weapon Against LGBT Rights

gay rights putin

Azerbaijan: The Rich Get Richer and the Poor Get Nothing

Baku

Emphasising the Incongruence Between the V4 Countries

Macron emerging europe

Moldova’s Briefly Suspended President is Still in Business

chisinau moldova parliament

After 25 Years of Restructuring, the Romanian Power Sector Is at a Crossroad

Impact of Brexit on EU-CEE Not Overstated

theresa may brexit

United or Divided? Europe in the Face of the Challenges of Tomorrow

Finalising the DCFTA is Expected to Bring Multiple Benefits to Ukraine

Moldova Falls Victim to Politicising

moldova emerging europe

Falling into Old Ways in 2017? Ukraine’s Struggle for Functioning Economic Institutions

Belarusian Journalists Still Face Huge Problems

PiS Uses Media Control to Bring Poland to Heel

Jaroslaw kaczynski pis emerging europe

The Global Outsourcing Industry — the Rise of the Phoenix

Azerbaijan, Georgia, Turkey Launch New ‘Silk Rail’ Link

Georgia is Returning to its Place at the European Table

georgia tbilisi

Regional Relations in the Western Balkans: Moving Beyond Folklore

Bosnia and Herzegovina flag with Serbia flag, 3D rendering

The Sharing Economy Could Bring New Business Models to CEE

Global Expansion in the Digital Age

Adam Smith’s Warning for Poland

The Netherlands’ Objection to the Ukraine-EU Association Agreement could be Costly to Europe

Euroscepticism in Serbia: An Image Problem?

Bank on Georgia

Background of Georgian Lari banknotes close up

Poland’s Confusing GDP Growth

Fiscal Policy Predictability in CEE — It’s Time for Change

After Its Significant Rise the Georgian Economy May Now Fall

Panorama of Tbilisi, Georgia in sunset rays. Vivid, saturated, splittoned image.

Albania’s Election Apathy

tirana albania

How Will Poland Approach the Brexit Negotiations?

Europe at Odds over OPAL and Nord Stream 2

The Long Tail of Global Expansion

Old Fashioned Skulduggery Overshadows the Elections in Moldova

Hungary’s Nationalist Assault on Free Enquiry

victor orban ceu

The CEE Region Is Making Advances in Prioritising Waste-to-Energy Projects

Sustainable Rooms

Rooms Hotel Khazbegi (courtesy of AGH)

Central and Eastern European Consumers Are Joining the Global Trends for Change

Brexit: Let’s Learn the Lesson and Hope a Better Europe Will Arise

Will Poland Leave the European Union?

polexit

Swimpassing Dniester Without Prejudice To Democracy

Parliament of the republic of moldova in chisinau, national flag, stefan cel mare street, spring time with blue sky

Will a Two-speed European Union Side-line the Visegrad Four?

Will the New Five-day Visa-free Regime Encourage More Visitors to Belarus?

Outsourcing in Germany: Stop Talking at and Start Talking to

CEE-Benefits and Disadvantages of Joining the Eurozone

forint zloty euro

E-lifestyle and Cyber Security: Some Views From Estonia

Cyber Security Protection Firewall Interface Concept

The GREAT London Food Scene

Bakery in London

Poland Challenges the European Identity

Poland emerging europe

Georgia’s Growth Continues

Batumi, Adjara, Georgia - May 27, 2016: Batumi, Adjara, Georgia. Gogebashvili Street Road And Marine Station Or Maritime Station Building Batumi On Background

Resignation in Ukraine: War, Revolution, Crisis — Some Things Never Change

Political Tensions Rise As Croatia Allegedly Breaks the Dublin III Refugee Regulation

croatia migrants

EU Visa-Liberalisation Strengthens Georgia’s Pro-Western Path

georgia emerging europe eu

Education Reform Key to Continued Georgian Success

tbilisi children

Good Match But Unlikely Marriage

Serbia’s New PM Is Cut From a Familiar Cloth

Serbian flag emerging europe

A Positive and Modern View of Entrepreneurship

Big Fish, Small Fish, Where to Fish? On the Eve of the Fourth Industrial Revolution

Business Moving Forward with Cautious Optimism — Can Investors Win the Confidence Game?

Measuring Growth of Societies with GDP Alone Shows an Incomplete Picture

Defending EU Values in Poland and Hungary

Eu hungary poland

How Will Trump’s Visit Affect Polish Politics?

Donald trump

European Volatility Makes Economic Development Slower for Ukraine

China: A Giant That Is Hard to Crack

Is the Level of Foreign Ownership a Problem in Emerging Europe?

Flags of European countries flying from their capital cities. Viewed from the South.

Georgian PM Reshapes and Reshuffles Cabinet

Giorgi Kvirikashvili

LGBT in CEE — A New Acceptance Is Being Born From Migration

Georgia’s Hospitality Sector Is Starting to Develop

georgia hospitality

The EU’s Choice: Fundamental Reform Or Disintegration

Under Promise, Over Deliver: Prospects for the EU’s Eastern Partnership in 2018

Eastern partnership

A Bosnian Referendum Shows Russia’s Influence in the Balkans—As Well As Its Limits

Macedonia’s Controversial Coalition Government

SKOPJE MACEDONIA emerging europe

Is the CEE Region About to Steal the Outsourcing Crown From India?

Amazing view on the Taj Mahal in sunset light with reflection in water. The Taj Mahal is an ivory-white marble mausoleum on the south bank of the Yamuna river. Agra Uttar Pradesh India.

A New Era for Georgian-German Economic Ties?

tbilisi georgia

Georgia: Leader of Europe’s Second Wave

Panorama view of Tbilisi capital of Georgia country. View from Narikala fortress. Cable road above tiled roofs.

The Competitive Edge in Central and Eastern Europe

SOFIA BULGARIA - MAY 5: View of the Ivan Vazov National Theatre in Sofia on May 5 2016. Sofia is the largest city and capital of Bulgaria.

Europe Needs To Be More Proactive In Embracing Armenia

Belarus 2020: Turning the Vicious Circle Into an Upward Spiral

Bulgaria Needs a Reform-Oriented Government to Take Full Advantage of its EU Membership

bulgaria emerging europe

Effective Policies Have Strengthened the Georgian Economy

TBILISI GEORGIA Jul. 18 2017: Bridge of Peace is a bow-shaped pedestrian bridge a steel and glass construction over the Kura River in downtown Tbilisi capital of Georgia

Is there any prospect of ‘Polexit’?

poland european union polexit

Slovenia’s Presidential Election: Pahor Expected to Romp Home

Slovenia flag against blue sky waving in wind

International Women’s Day — Let’s Take Action And Then Celebrate

Romania Surviving the Waves of Recent Political Tsunamis in Europe

High Dollarisation the Largest Challenge for Georgia’s National Bank

History as Destiny? Institutional Erosion in Ukraine and Poland

Hungary and Israel: the Collision of Past and Present

Budapest synagoge

The Right to Water: Who Can Change Today’s Situation?

Poland’s Capital Saturation Lower Than the Czech Republic’s

deloitte fdi poland

Poland’s Drift Away From Democracy

January Kicks Off an Exciting Year for Emerging Europe

The Voice of European Business Must Be Heard Loud and Clear by Brexit Negotiators

Nagorno-Karabakh Conflict Moves from Frozen to Kinetic

Nagorno-Karabakh

Young Georgians Make Their Mark at Emerging Europe-EBRD Event

maximilien lambertson at emergeing ebrd outlook on georgia

Are Labour Shortages Driving Economic Growth?

EU-CEE Is Still Growing at a Healthy Rate

Prague emerging europe

The Capital Markets Union: a New Beginning in the European Financial Sector?

Partnership is the Key to CEE-Indian Business

Czech Own Currency Insures Against Euro Losses

Euro Czech republic emerging europe

Polish Tax Laws — Fighting a Winning Battle Against Tax Evaders

Could the West At Least Help Ukraine To Insure FDI Against Political Risks?

Emerging Europe Back on Track to Convergence

wiiw

Prepare for a New Europe

Breaking With Imitations of the Past

Can Armenia Keep a Foot in Both Camps?

European union armenia russia emerging europe

Poland Needs to Cling to the Eurozone

zloty euro emerging europe

Changing Perspectives and Showing That True Romania is a Vibrant Innovative Country

Why is Armenia Borrowing Another 100 Million US Dollars From Russia?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *