News

New report suggests democracy in Poland is at risk

“The model of liberal democracy is coming under increasing pressure in the OECD and the EU,” explains Daniel Schraad-Tischler, senior analyst and co-author of the study Policy Performance and Governance Capacities in the OECD and EU, carried out by BertelsmannStiftung and published on October 9. “In some countries, central democratic and constitutional standards – freedom of the media, for example – are already heavily damaged.”

The report makes clear that there has been a general decline in democracy across the EU and OECD countries. Some emerging Europe countries are amongst the biggest offenders.

Overall, the aggregated results of the SGI 2018 show a significant decline in the quality of democracy in OECD and EU countries, with 26 countries experiencing a deterioration in the quality of democracy, which is relatively pronounced in 19 of them.

“It is also alarming, that despite the declining quality in democracy, citizens’ trust in government has actually increased in countries like Poland, Hungary and Turkey,” states Dr Schraad-Tischler. “This development illustrates that, in these countries, fundamental democratic values don’t seem to be sufficiently anchored in the political consciousness of a large part of the population.”

The most worrying case is in respect to Poland, which has fallen 29 places to 37th (out of 41 countries ranked). Since the publication of the last report in 2014, The Law and Justice Party (PiS) have taken over control of the government to such an extent that reforms put in place have effectively put into question the independence of several institutions, in particular the judiciary.

“The first activities of the new government targeted the Constitutional Tribunal, public media and civil service. During its second year in office, the government turned to reducing the political independence of the Supreme Court, the National Council of the Judiciary and ordinary courts,” explains the report.

Yet its not only the judiciary that came under attack: the political liberties of Poland’s citizens have also been effected:

“Political liberties have suffered from new restrictions on rights of assembly, increasing harassment by the police and growing government control of NGO funding. The quality of democracy has also been affected by the government’s strong discourse against Muslims, the LGBT community and ‘gender ideology’, as well as increasing corruption and cronyism in state-owned enterprises, and political polarisation,” the report adds.

In general, Poland’s fall from grace has more to do with political unrest in the country, and PiS’s quest to reform legislation quickly. Its ongoing conflict with the EU has not helped.

“The PiS government’s political course has done more damage to Poland’s international reputation. The government’s attempts to control the judiciary prompted massive protests internationally. In the European Union, there have been calls to launch formal proceedings against Poland for breaching European common values and the rule of law, and to cut financial transfers to Poland and restrict Poland’s voting rights in the European Council,” explains the report.

On a more positive note, both Estonia and Lithuania made it the top 10. Estonia in seventh, up three places since 2014, and Lithuania 10th, up two places.

“In many respects, Estonia has proven successful in building a sustainable democracy. After 12 years of governing coalitions dominated by the neoliberal Reform Party, a centre-left government led by the Centre Party has been installed. This new government has prioritised policies aiming to secure the financial sustainability of the welfare system and increase social inclusion,” the report explains.

4 Comments

Click here to post a comment

  • I have lived in Germany for many years and I can say honestly: Polish democracy is much more robust than in Germany. There is no freedom of the press in Germany. The German press is a mouthpiece for the German government. So I do not trust rankings like this.

  • Poland had 5 presidents 1989-2015. Four Communists … and the other blown up in mid-air, with no meaningful investigation. Rule of law??
    Leading newspaper Rzeczpospolita (part state-owned) reported on the air crash in a way that annoyed Tusk – he sold the paper to a friendly oligarch and half the journalists were sacked. Tusk also arranged for the editor of Fakt to be sacked because he wasn’t sufficiently pro-Tusk. Freedom of speech??
    The independent public prosecutors allowed massive illegal importation of Russian fuel – worth billions a year in 2010-2015. Alerted by Customs and the Internal Security Agency (which also alerted Tusk, their titular head), the prosecutors said it was OK because the illegal importation was okayed by “the very top”. Rule of law??
    The City of Warsaw “returned” EUR 5 billion of property stolen by the Communists. Great news, you’d think. Except the property wasn’t returned to the former owners – who the judges believed in good faith to be 130 years old and unable to attend court – but to their mafiosi representatives. The Liberal Mayor helped herself to a Holocaust asset worth EUR millions. Rule of law??
    The City of Warsaw’s property restitution program led directly to 50,000 low-end tenants being evicted. One tenants’ rights campaigner Jola Brzeska was abducted, taken to a forest, hand tied behind her back and burnt alive. The police claimed it was suicide and only started their investigation after all CCTV footage had been deleted. Rule of law?? And it was years before the story was reported outside of Poland.
    Media. Pre-2015 All 3 major channels held identical views, Soviet style. Not surprising, really. TVN – set up by the Communist secret police, Polsat – set up by the Communist secret police (and still owned by a spook), TVN – legacy state-owned channel, all friends and family of the last Central Committee. Freedom of speech??

    • Typo …
      Media. Pre-2015 all 3 major channels held identical views, Soviet style. Not surprising, really. TVN – set up by the Communist secret police, Polsat – set up by the Communist secret police (and still owned by a spook), TVP – legacy state-owned channel, all friends and family of the last Central Committee. Freedom of speech??

  • Bertelsmann Stiftung reported how great things were under Tusk and Komorowski. Great insight!! Massive illegal dealings with Putin – no problems for the German government there!
    Hmmm … Komorowski.
    Let’s have a look at his background, shall we?
    1980s – he was officially a history teacher at the school Siotr Niepokolanek. He was on the list of teachers, got paid every month … it’s just that my contacts there told me he never taught a lesson. Interesting, it gets better. Famously semi-literate, he apparently ran an underground, opposition newspaper that no-one has heard of and was very knowledgeable about people planning anti-state activities.
    In completely unrealted news, his father infiltrated the Home Army resistance group (anti-Communist). His unit was captured and Komorowski (father) immediately became an officer in the Polish People’s Army. Meaning – he was a Communist agent.
    Great Liberal credentials!